Experience all the charm of historic Cape May at Lilly's Butterscotch Cottage on the idyllic S. Broadway!

This beautiful, historic home has a total of 5 bedrooms, and 5 full baths. First-floor bedroom/full bath, large porch, back deck, huge private yard, and parking! Three blocks to the beach and promenade! Walking distance to all Cape May has to offer. Enjoy ocean breezes on a large front porch, comfortably furnished with two seating areas for relaxing and entertaining. Enjoy the large dining room table for family meals, puzzles, and game nights. The comfortably furnished family room leads to a full bath with a new claw foot tub, original pocket doors, with a first-floor bedroom with a queen bed.

The eat-in kitchen leads to a deck, patio, and large yard perfect for outdoor meals, grilling, and lawn games. Convenient first-floor laundry room. The second floor has three bedrooms and three full bathrooms. One queen bedroom with en suite full bath, spacious master bedroom with large master bathroom across the hall with new claw foot tub, and a bedroom with two twins and hall bathroom with stall shower. The third floor has a unique set up with a private bedroom with a queen bed, a full bath across the hall with shower/tub combo, and a family room and full kitchen with all amenities.

The expansive Broadway beach has a snack shack, bathrooms, and a view of the lighthouse. A breakfast place and restaurant are also near the beach. One block up from the house is ice cream, pizza, Sapore Italian restaurant, Viggiano's Restaurant, Grana BYOB, Key West Tacos, convenience stores, shopping, Cape May Wicker, Exit Zero Restaurant, West End Antiques, Beach Plum Bakery and the lovely Wilbraham Park for walking, home of the famous Lima Bean Festival. CVS Pharmacy and a grocery store are within walking distance. Easily walk to the main shopping area Washington Street "Mall", church, many restaurants, and mini golf. Walk the beach or use the promenade, while taking in the historic homes.

This house is a very short drive or hearty bike ride to the lighthouse, wineries, farm markets, the famous sunken concrete ship, WW II lookout tower, and many other interesting activities. Perfect house for extended families, reunions, or corporate events. Great escape for a girl's week away or a guy's golf outing. Lots of privacy for all. Parking for 2 cars, hardwood throughout first and second floors, Ceiling fans in every bedroom, air conditioner throughout. Enjoy your stay historic in Cape May, the southernmost point in New Jersey!

Additionally includes 2 tickets to a production of your choice for the 2026-2027 season at Cape May Stage!

Eat around the shore with included gift certificates to Grana BYOB in Cape May and goodies plus a gift certificate to Mamma Lena's Trattoria and Martina's in Ventnor, New Jersey!

Pertinent Terms & Conditions

4 nights, 5 days. Cannot be redeemed June-September or 1st week of December. Must be reserved 6 months within winning.

Donated by Noelle & Christian Noyes, Cape May Stage, Grana BYOB, and Mamma Lena's Trattoria, Martina's