Cagney the Musical kicks off the 2026 summer season in the Hamptons at the famous Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor.

This fabulous award-winning musical starring the multi-talented Robert Creighton, had a sold-out 15-month run at the West Side Theater in New York.
You'll love the classic George M. Cohen music and amazing tap dancing to songs like "Yankee Doodle Dandy," "Give My Regards to Broadway" and "Grand Old Flag."

Bid to win 4 house seats to Cagney PLUS a full-course dinner before or after the show at the legendary American Hotel in Sag Harbor.

Cagney runs the entire month of June - so choose your performance now before it's sold out!

Own an original and one of a kind "musical doodle" by Lynn Ahrens and Stephen Flaherty!

The musical doodle features a line from "Back to Before" from their iconic and award winning musical Ragtime and includes a signed drawing of Lincoln Center's Ragtime marquee.

Enjoy lunch with award-winning New York Times' journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin.

Andrew Ross Sorkin is an award-winning journalist for The New York Times and a co-anchor of CNBC's Squawk Box. Sorkin is also the founder and editor-at-large of DealBook, a news site published by the Times. He is the best-selling author of 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History--And How It Shattered a Nation, and Too Big to Fail: The Inside Story of How Wall Street and Washington Fought to Save the Financial System and Themselves. Sorkin co-produced an HBO adaptation of Too Big To Fail, which was nominated for 11 Emmy Awards. He is also co-creator of Showtime's drama series Billions. He has won numerous journalistic honors, including two Gerald Loeb Awards, and is a member of the Council on Foreign Relations. He started writing for the Times in 1995, while still in high school.

Support new works

Enjoy lunch with award-winning New York Times' journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin.

Andrew Ross Sorkin is an award-winning journalist for The New York Times and a co-anchor of CNBC's Squawk Box. Sorkin is also the founder and editor-at-large of DealBook, a news site published by the Times. He is the best-selling author of 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History--And How It Shattered a Nation, and Too Big to Fail: The Inside Story of How Wall Street and Washington Fought to Save the Financial System and Themselves. Sorkin co-produced an HBO adaptation of Too Big To Fail, which was nominated for 11 Emmy Awards. He is also co-creator of Showtime's drama series Billions. He has won numerous journalistic honors, including two Gerald Loeb Awards, and is a member of the Council on Foreign Relations. He started writing for the Times in 1995, while still in high school.

Enjoy a private 90-minute tour of the iconic New York City Landmark for up to 8 people and afterwards treat yourself to a meal at the Grand Brasserie with a $150 gift certificate.

The Municipal Art Society (MAS) has been leading tours of New York's famous Grand Central Terminal longer than any other tour operator. In fact, MAS saved Grand Central back in the 1970s with the legendary help of our board member Jacqueline Onassis.

Enjoy a private 2-hour walking tour of the West Village on a Sunday morning with up to 12 guests!

Afterwards enjoy brunch at the beautiful West Village's Little Hen with a $100 gift card!

Enjoy two tickets to see Broadway's Hadestown.

See Death Becomes Her on Broadway and enjoy a backstage meet and greet with Tony Nominee Christopher Sieber after the show.

Own a piece of theatre history with a signed note from Stephen Sondheim.

This personal note, dated June 23, 1987, references Sondheim's work on the upcoming productions of Follies and Into the Woods.

Host a party in your home or office for up to 25 guests with hors d'oeuvres and minis. Dish will provide up to two staff members for up to 3 hours.

Enjoy a game at Yankee's Stadium from the best seats in the house--the Legend's Suite!

Package includes two tickets to a Yankees home game, seats in the Legend's Suite, and a parking pass.

Enjoy two seats to Broadway's Chicago, a private dance lesson with a Merry Murderess of Cook County Jail Kristen Oui, and meet her after for the show for a backstage tour of the Ambassador Theatre.

Enjoy two seats to the 2025-2026 Lyrics & Lyricists season at the 92nd Street Y, New York. This season celebrates the work of Paul Williams, the artists of Tin Pan Alley and the love story of Marilyn & Alan Bergman.

Enjoy two house seats to Broadway's Just in Time and a backstage tour with one of the show's creators, Ted Chapin!

Enjoy all the New York Cabaret season has to offer with two tickets to a show at Joe's Pub and 54 Below!

Take four of your friends for a Portfolio Tasting at Millbrook Winery in Millbrook, NY! Enjoy six exceptional wines of your choice and take home a souvenir glass from the estate!

Enjoy dinner at the House of Stefas after an afternoon of wine tasting at Millbrook Vineyard and Winery with a gift certificate!

Own a one-of-a-kind piece of musical theatre history with a handwritten sheet music of "Sunrise, Sunset" from Broadway's Fiddler on the Roof, signed by Sheldon Harnick himself!

Enjoy a private 1-hour tap lesson with award-winning director, choreographer, and performer, Randy Skinner, whose work has been seen on Broadway, National and International tours, and Regional theatres.

Spend an hour honing your skills with Tony Nominee and Drama Desk Winning actor Marc Kudisch (Thoroughly Modern Millie, Assassins and 9 to 5).

Get one-on-one time to work through monologues, scenes and discuss the business of theatre!

Dress it up or dress it down with a beautiful necklace from RJP Gems. This necklace features 6 amethyst stones and grey pearls, with a front CZ fasten and large Druzy Stone.

See the magic of Disney with two seats to Broadway's The Lion King! After the show enjoy a backstage tour with the associate costume designer, Stacey Stephens!

Enjoy lunch or dinner at the West Bank Cafe with a $100 gift certificate before heading over to the Signature to enjoy any show in their 2025/2026 season with two tickets.

Root for the home team with four of your closest friends when the New York Jets take on the Miami Dolphins at Met Life Stadium on Sunday, December 7th.

Enjoy the game in Section 135, row 5!

Enjoy 2 seats to Broadway's MJ the Musical and afterwards go backstage with the show's musical director, Michael O. Mitchell!

Spend a summer night under the stars in the newly renovated Delacorte Theatre with two tickets to an opening night performance of Shakespeare in the Park in their 2026 season.

Enjoy access to the opening night party in the Park following the show!

Step up your style and vision with a $150 gift card to Caddis Eyewear where you can pick your perfect frame or accessories. Whether you're looking for bold readers, blue light blockers, or a fresh new look, Caddis brings modern design and quality into focus.

Own a signed copy of New York Times' Andrew Ross Sorkin's best selling books 1929 and Too Big to Fail with a personalized note from the author himself!